April 18, 2026
Listening to: Alone Alone by excape. ♫
Lately, there've been new voices in my head when I sit to write. They're not characters. They're critics throwing me straitjackets and chains and whispered questions like—'Do you have the right to write this? Have you lived the experience, and does your experience fit the perfect statistic narrative?' before my fingertips touch the keys. It's this creeping policing of the imagination. A pressure to be perfectly sensitive. And it forces a character into a role of a representative that it never asked to be in.
If we only write what we have lived, and even tiptoeing around our own stories to ensure it won't offend anyone, are we still writing fiction, or are we writing echo chambers, lectures, memoirs?
And is the push for sensitivity readers about making better art and ensuring factual information, or is it an insurance policy against a witch hunt? What I mean is this—I've always believed talking to people with lived experience while building a character naturally weaves authenticity into the DNA of the story. That is the job as the author: research. But when someone is hired at the very end to "scrub" or approve a finished manuscript, it risks treating human experiences like a liability check rather than part of the creative craft. In the last few years, even, some authors and publishers have pointed to their use of sensitivity readers when backlash hit, using their involvement as a shield against criticism rather than taking full accountability for the finished work.
Writers are supposed to take full responsibility for every word on the page, including the risks and imperfections.
I know: words have teeth and lazy cliches can leave real scars—I'm not ignoring that. But there is a difference between doing the work to get the details right and dictating who has the right to write it and how policing the art of storytelling. Writing is a lonely, vulnerable act of expression as is, and I believe no one should self-insert themselves into another's process and dictate how it's done. If we become too afraid to imagine a soul that is not our own, we aren't writing fiction anymore, but building walls around our own experiences.
[side note: speaking of self-insertion] One of my author friends just this morning sent me a video of Danielle L. Jensen, author of A Fate Inked In Blood. In this video she talks about the rise of readers needing to self-insert themselves into the main character, needing them to look, act, feel a certain way. This expectation extends beyond authors and sensitivity readers to the way we approach characters as readers. I'm going to quote her directly because I couldn't have said it better: 'The beautiful thing about writing and fiction is that you are creating a person with totally different experiences that the reader can get to know and understand why certain people would do certain things. It is how you get empathy and how you grow your understanding of a diverse spectrum of experiences."
It challenges me to think—could we reach a point where sensitivity readers will one day have more influence over how things should be than the thorny truth of how things actually are?
Art is supposed to be the one place where we're allowed to be messy, wrong, daring, honest. But the book community as a whole has become obsessed with being right safety. So much so that I'm afraid one day no one will know what it feels like to sit with uncomfortability. (Yes, I could say discomfort, but uncomfortability feels more... uncomfortable.) It's literally impossible to balance the wild of fiction with a checklist to make sure no one is ever offended. And with doing so, are we accidentally killing the core of what keeps these stories human?
I'm going to be real with you—since puberty, I've always had severe acne. I've been called names that've made me cry, been bullied, teased, rejected. If I projected this into my characters, let my experience play out through the story, no one would know I've lived this unless I'd stated it. And the way I'd write it would absolutely be hurtful and damaging because that's what it was to me. If I removed this part so no one else would hurt, I'm invalidating my pain and the pain of others who've felt the same, replacing it with toxic positivity. (I first published this in my newsletter and received a reply stating acne is nowhere near the reason we need sensitivity readers, that there are far worse troubles, such as mental health, weight, trauma experience such as rape. That email alone only reinforced my entire purpose for discussing this in the first place. Ranking one person's suffering against someone else's doesn't prove why we need sensitivity readers. It illustrates exactly what I'm questioning: that suffering belongs to the individual, and no two people are required to experience it, respond to it, or overcome it in the same way. So why should their fictional counterparts?)
I know my stance on sensitivity readers is controversial, and I'm not saying research doesn't matter or that we should be intentionally hurtful. I'm saying that if we keep choosing palatability over real, if we keep modifying stories so they're easier to swallow, we end up with books that have no heartbeat.
I don't know. I didn't come here with answers, only questions to think about. Creative expression used to feel unchained. More abandon between author and story. More space, too. A carte blanche—a French term meaning an artist has total authority to do whatever they want. And if you've been following me since the beginning, you know that there's one thing I fight for in fiction: freedom.
If you've made it this far, I appreciate you taking a front row seat to my thoughts and rambling.
I'm curious to know your thoughts on this as well. Is it something you've thought about while reading? Have you seen the change over the years, and is it going in a direction you're happy with?
all my love
